Slow voltage variations: The silent killer for your efficiency

Slow voltage variations are structural deviations from the rated voltage (usually 230V or 400V) that persist for longer than a few minutes. Unlike short voltage dips, which are immediately visible through flashing lights or breakdowns, prolonged undervoltage or overvoltage cause invisible wear, overheating of motors and unexplained failures in sensitive equipment.

In the ideal world, the sinusoidal alternating voltage is constant. In practice, voltage fluctuates continuously due to load variations and renewable energy generation. When these variations go beyond the legal or technical limits (as defined in EN50160), the operational reliability of your installation is at risk. As a specialist in Power Quality, HyTEPS helps you analyse the cause and stabilise the voltage.

In brief: What you need to know about voltage variations

The phenomenon: A long-term deviation (higher or lower) from the rated voltage, often caused by heavy loads, long cables or decentralised generation (solar/wind).

The risk: Undervoltage leads to overheating of motors (due to higher current consumption) and failure of control systems. Overvoltage drastically shortens the lifetime of electronics and lighting.

The standard: According to EN50160, the voltage should not deviate by more than 10% during 95% of the week. However, for critical processes, this margin is often too wide.

The solution: always start with a Power Quality measurement to determine whether the problem lies internally (your installation) or externally (the grid operator).

For whom is voltage stability critical?

This article is written for Installation Managers, Technical Managers and Engineers in environments where electricity availability is directly linked to operational results. Think of:

Utility with a lot of PV: Where feed-in provides local voltage boost.

Industry & Manufacturing: Where electric motors, pumps and conveyors run continuously.

Data centres: where UPS systems trigger unnecessarily when voltage deviations occur, leading to battery wear.

Healthcare (Hospitals): Where sensitive medical imaging equipment (MRI/CT) requires tight voltage tolerances.

What exactly are slow voltage variations?

Technically, we speak of slow voltage variations when the effective value (RMS) of the voltage deviates from the nominal voltage (Un) for an extended period (standard 10 minutes).

A simple comparison: Imagine voltage as the water pressure in your shower.

  • A voltage drop is like someone flushing a toilet elsewhere in the building: the pressure drops for half a second and immediately returns.
  • Slow undervoltage is like the main water pipe is too narrow for the entire neighbourhood: every evening around 6pm, when everyone showers, the pressure is structurally too low. You can't get the soap out of your hair properly and the geyser might even turn off.

In electrical terms:

  1. Undervoltage (Undervoltage): The voltage drops below the threshold value (e.g. < 207V in a 230V grid) for an extended period of time.
  2. Overvoltage (OverVoltage): Voltage rises above the threshold value (e.g. > 253V) for a prolonged period.

Nuance: Do not confuse this with transient overvoltages (spikes caused by lightning or switching) or voltage dips (short interruptions). Slow variations are about the 'steady state' condition of your installation.

The impact on your plant: Why ignoring is not an option

Many plant managers trust that equipment will "keep on doing it". This is often true, but at what cost?

1. Undervoltage and motors (The hidden cost) Many industrial loads are 'constant power' loads. If the voltage (U) drops, the current (I) must increase to deliver the same power (P) (P = U x I).

  • Impact: A 10% drop in voltage can lead to a current increase of more than 10%. Since heat generation increases quadratically with current (Ploss = I2 x R), the temperature in motor windings can increase by 20-30%. This halves the lifetime of the insulation.

2. Overvoltage and electronics Modern LED lighting and switching power supplies are sensitive. Prolonged overvoltage overloads capacitors and semiconductors.

  • Result: LED drivers that fail after two years instead of after 10 years.

3. Process failure Control systems (PLCs) and protection relays have undervoltage protection. If the voltage drops too far, the machine shuts down to protect itself.

  • Result: unplanned downtime and production loss.

Symptoms in practice

Do you recognise any of the following signs? Then chances are you are dealing with voltage variations.

  • Thermal failure: Motors regularly fail on thermal protection even though they do not appear mechanically overloaded.
  • Flashing lighting: not rapid flickering, but lamps that visibly dim or become brighter during certain parts of the day.
  • UPS activity: Uninterruptible Power Supplies (UPS) regularly switch to battery operation while the power does not fail completely.
  • Generator start: emergency generators strike without total blackout.

The Causes: Internal or External?

To solve the problem, we need to know where it comes from.

1. External causes (The public grid)

The system operator (DSO) provides voltage, but its quality varies depending on your location in the network.

  • End of line: Are you at the end of a long distribution cable? Then the voltage is often lower due to the voltage drop across the cable distance.
  • Heavy neighbours: Is a neighbouring company starting heavy machinery? This can pull down voltage throughout the neighbourhood grid.
  • High-voltage transformer: The position of the 'tap changer' in the transformer station determines the voltage level. Sometimes it is fixed at too high or too low a value.

2. Internal causes (Your installation)

Often the cause lies within their own gates.

  • Wiring too thin or too long: According to NEN 1010, the voltage loss in your own installation should be no more than 3-5%. With expansions, this is often exceeded.
  • Large inrush currents: Simultaneous switching on large motors or compressors.
  • Solar photovoltaics (PV): To feed energy back, inverters need to increase voltage locally. On sunny days, this can lead to overvoltage, causing inverters to switch themselves off.

Solutions: From 'Quick Win' to Structural

Have you found that voltage variations are disrupting your process? Here are the possible interventions.

1. Adjust tap settings transformer Do you have your own medium-voltage transformer? Often, the primary winding can be adjusted via a 'tap changer'. This increases or decreases the secondary voltage structurally.

  • Benefit: Inexpensive.
  • Disadvantage: It is a fixed adjustment; it does not dynamically adjust with load variations.

2. Optimise cabling Reduce voltage drop by weighting cables or shortening cable runs.

  • Benefit: Structural, passive solution.
  • Disadvantage: Often expensive and invasive in existing buildings.

3. Active Voltage Conditioning (AVC) An AVC is a system that continuously monitors voltage and corrects it at lightning speed. When there is a dip, the system adds energy; when there is a peak, it regulates back.

  • Benefit: Guarantees a perfect sine wave regardless of grid quality.
  • Disadvantage: investment in hardware.

4. Reactive power compensation (Capacitor bank) By reducing reactive power (power factor improvement), the current through the cables decreases and with it the voltage drop.

  • Benefit: Also reduces your energy bill and relieves the burden on the transformer.

Beware of these pitfalls

  • Mistake 1: Blindly relying on the multimeter. A standard multimeter measures a snapshot in time. Slow variations require trend analysis over days or weeks.
  • Error 3: Fighting symptoms. Adjusting a thermal protection device ever higher does not solve the undervoltage, but increases the likelihood of the motor burning.
  • Mistake 4: Blaming the grid operator directly. In many cases, the problem arises behind the meter. Without measurement, you have no proof.

Roadmap: Get a grip on your voltage

  1. Inventory: Map which equipment fails and when. Is there a pattern (e.g. Monday morning start-up)?
  2. Measurement: Have a Power Quality measurement carried out (at least one week) to get a complete profile of voltage, current and power.
  3. Cause determination: Correlate voltage drops with switch-on times of internal processes.
  4. Solution: in consultation with an engineer, choose the right measure (Trafo adjustment, AVC, Wiring).

Read more about Power Quality

Frequently asked questions

Answer:

Symptoms are often subtle until things go wrong. Look out for unexplained machine failures, flickering lights, cables getting hot or transformers buzzing. Also, if electronics (PLCs, drivers) fail earlier than the service life indicates, chances are that the power quality is insufficient. A Power Quality measurement provides the answer.

Answer:

This is possible, provided you have a high-quality Power Quality Analyzer (according to IEC 61000-4-30 Class A) and the knowledge to interpret the data. Collecting data is easy; analysing the correlation between events, harmonics and your specific business processes requires specialist engineering knowledge. We are happy to support you in the analysis.

Answer:

Not by definition. NEN-EN 50160 describes the minimum requirements for voltage at the grid operator's transfer point. However, modern equipment can be more sensitive and malfunction even if the voltage is within this standard. We therefore look beyond the standard: we look at the compatibility between your power supply and your connected load.

Answer:

Peace of mind, certainty and insight. You get a clear diagnosis of the 'health' of your electrical installation. We pinpoint the cause of faults, enabling you to avoid unplanned downtime and reduce fire risks or unnecessary energy losses. You receive a concrete advisory report with practical points for improvement.

Answer:

No, that is a misconception. A filter is a powerful tool, but not a panacea. Sometimes the solution lies in changing transformer settings, redistributing loads or adjusting cabling. HyTEPS always recommends a thorough analysis and simulation before we recommend hardware, to avoid unnecessary investments.

Answer:

Yes, significantly. Solar panel inverters and LED lighting drivers are non-linear loads that cause harmonics and sometimes supraharmonics. This can lead to interference with other equipment or overloading of the neutral conductor. When renovating or preserving, a Power Quality check is essential to ensure operational reliability.

Answer:

We call this phenomenon 'nuisance tripping'. Often the cause is not the total amount of current, but the distortion of the current (harmonics) or short peak currents that your measuring equipment misses. This contamination can extra heat up thermal protections or confuse electronic protections, causing them to switch off wrongly. A specialised measurement can find out exactly why a protection reacts.

Answer:

For a reliable picture, we usually measure at least one to two weeks. This is necessary to capture a full duty cycle, including weekends and peak loads. For specific acute failures, we can also take short-term measurements or deploy 'continuous waveform recording' to capture transients.

Answer:

Your installer is an expert in installation and maintenance (the 'general practitioner'). HyTEPS is the specialist (the 'Power Quality Doctor'). We have advanced measuring equipment, simulation software and in-depth knowledge of theoretical electrical engineering and regulations. We often work together with installers to solve complex puzzles that fall outside standard knowledge.

Answer:

After the measurement, you receive a report with conclusions in understandable language as well as technical details. If necessary, we simulate the possible solutions in our software. So you know exactly what the effect of a measure will be in advance. We then supervise the implementation and verify the result with a follow-up measurement.

In doubt about the quality of your voltage?

Don't wait for motors to fail or production to stop. With a temporary measurement or continuous monitoring, our engineers can precisely identify whether slow voltage variations pose a risk to your installation.

HyTEPS

Beemdstraat 3

5653 MA Eindhoven